• An announcement has been posted regarding the data loss and rollback to February 8, 2026 data. The thread can be viewed here.

The Problem With Giant's Lair..

As a complete outsider to this situation; it is REALLY disappointing to see.

I'm a person that disagrees with a lot of things, however I very heavily sympathize with what this community has had to go through as a result. No one person or group deserves to be targeted like this in a place like this. This is a fucking Garry's Mod TTT and Minecraft community. We should be talking about Garry's Mod and Minecraft updates; not what happening in the US, not what's happening in the world, nothing like that. We should be talking about Mojang adding new animals and how Garry doesn't care about this game anymore.

You are all too online. You want to think of what is "right" but don't understand that your own thoughts are being influenced by things around you, how others perceive you, and by your own preconception of how someone might perceive you as a member of this "community," rather than being authentic to one another. It seems like you idiots can't see another living human being's point of view on a situation, and would rather villainize someone over an arbitrary ruleset, than try to see where they're coming from and humanize with them.

You all want to be friends, you all want to be with the "in group." You want everyone to get along and be so close to each other, but fail to see that as long as you have a policing force in the community you can never truly have equals. The policing body is always going to be close with one another, and be the "face" of the community. And because of that the community members that frequent this space are going to want to be close with that "popular group," who is actually actively waiting for them to makes a mistake and punish them for it. The community member that was trying to have an honest moment of connection with the "face of the community" and subsequently gets punished for it, is obviously going to bear resent towards you.

That's never going to work. We've seen it happen what, 4 or 6 times now? STTT almost died 3-4 times; finally did and then you guys went through 3 different communities and never learned that this whole popularity contest is what kills the community ever single fucking time. You can't keep making this exclusive "in group" within the community and then wondering why the rest of the community eventually ends up rebelling against that "in group" with a misappropriate power to the people.

You guys are all fucking idiots, have never made a community full of equals, and then wondered why everyone gets mad at each other. THE STAFF TEAM IS THE REAL COMMUNITY. YOU ALL SELECTIVELY CHOOSE ONE ANOTHER AND THEN GET UPSET WHEN THE UNCHOOSEN STICK AROUND INSTEAD OF TELLING THEM THAT THEY'RE UNWELCOME!! You want to say you will include everyone, but obviously ignore the very clear reasons as to why not everyone gets along and why certain people were removed from the past communities.

A lot of the discussion lately has been about how this community is repeating past failures, and how it's going to fail. Yet none of you are talking about how you're going to change and better yourselves in order to keep going. Jabba made an announcement about changes, and some of you have expressed your displeasure with that. But he's the only one actively trying to do something different, actually take a stance and remove the people he doesn't like and deems an adversary to the community and to the "in group." Yet I already know that you guys are gonna keep clinging on to your weak hope and desires, sweep this whole thing under the rug because enough of you decided to put up with it, keep your mouth shut and keep pushing onto the next day. But guess what? This dickhead Jabba tried to give you all a space, but YOU motherfuckers allowed this to happen again. You couldn't get along with each other because maybe you wanted to part of the "popular kids" as well, but look at where it got you guys again.

You guys decided to form another clique within each other and the community, and then want to act confused when the community isn't one cohesive group that gets along with each other.

Hopefully in the next attempt at a community or discord server you guys will realize that you really want it to be an "invite only" kind of place and not make the weak attempt at including everyone. Or maybe give the community more autonomy on what happens here. I don't know, your TTT server isn't even active enough for me to be here enough. I'm just a slut for drama. 🐒 good luck retards
zero skin in the game, so take my opinion with the largest grain of salt imaginable

i'd prob phrase it in a nicer way, but tz is spitting nothing but facts here. the biggest problem at sgm was always the concept of the "in group", it just felt like high school but in a video game 90% of the time. the "in group" would occasionally change, but there was always a clear hierarchy of "these are the important people, and then there's everyone else". if you weren't connected to that group, your opinions were either invalid, disregarded, wrong, or if you were actually right, the rules were changed to make you wrong. my only warning point on the sgm forums was posting in a ban appeal at the request of the person appealing as i had evidence, which should have been more than acceptable due to them asking me in the thread to appeal, however i was still given a warning bc the "in group" didn't want to be questioned by me. the only way to actually fix things is to be brutally honest about the issues being faced and doing everything in your power to bring about change, not by reacting with "confusing" to the one post that actually calls out the problem.

or just ignore the problem. like tz said, surely it won't happen a 7th, 8th, 9th, or even 15th time
 
I joined GL for TTT. Sad to see yet another server with a good community die because the staff team feels the need to run a dictatorship amongst the player base. At the end of the day its a videogame that people(such as myself) like to play at the end of the day to unwind, but playing GL TTT felt more of a chore than anything. The people who brought engagement on the server were banned(im not super informed on all the details, but understand the broad scope from this post) and when it was called out 80% of the staff team went running. Damn shame. Love to see the community as a whole stand up for each other, hate to see the people chosen to protect said community lose sight of what they signed up for.
RIP Giant's Lair
After a recent member left the community a lot of new information(for me) was put out for the community to read. Absolutely DISGUSTING. I'm very happy Proper and Frosty were banned and honestly think their ban should be permanent. In my personal opinion the following users should also be banned; Coriander(how the fuck is this guy a mod???), Tiefling Lesbian, and especially bone ore. How can you get off and feel happy about belittling and demonizing a religion that someone follows due to current events going on in the world, so much so they LEAVE a community of people they assumed were "friends". Very confused as to how someone can get off on thinking their shit doesn't stink while simultaneously comparing people to Nazis and persistently making antisemitic jokes. Please grow up, talk to a therapist and really do a through self evaluation (most likely wont). Giants Lair NEEDS to be better, there should be no platform for these appalling individuals.
 
After a recent member left the community a lot of new information(for me) was put out for the community to read. Absolutely DISGUSTING. I'm very happy Proper and Frosty were banned and honestly think their ban should be permanent. In my personal opinion the following users should also be banned; Coriander(how the fuck is this guy a mod???), Tiefling Lesbian, and especially bone ore. How can you get off and feel happy about belittling and demonizing a religion that someone follows due to current events going on in the world, so much so they LEAVE a community of people they assumed were "friends". Very confused as to how someone can get off on thinking their shit doesn't stink while simultaneously comparing people to Nazis and persistently making antisemitic jokes. Please grow up, talk to a therapist and really do a through self evaluation (most likely wont). Giants Lair NEEDS to be better, there should be no platform for these appalling individuals.
this is stupid you are stupid
 
You think its stupid that a member of the Giant's Lair community no longer felt welcome due to the blatant antisemitic comments, jokes and statements? Interesting take! Thank you for resigning :)

I think you need to educate yourself on geopolitics and the difference between Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism before making blanket statements. I'll make it easy for you: one is prejudice against Jews and one is opposition to a nationalist movement based on establishing a Jewish homeland through "colonization" that has lead to the genocide of the Palestinians.

Also, you were banned from Basically Vanilla for CP jokes so I'm not going to take your opinions seriously.
 
I think you need to educate yourself on geopolitics and the difference between Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism before making blanket statements. I'll make it easy for you: one is prejudice against Jews and one is opposition to a nationalist movement based on establishing a Jewish homeland through "colonization" that has lead to the genocide of the Palestinians.

Also, you were banned from Basically Vanilla for CP jokes so I'm not going to take your opinions seriously.
Im aware, but a person who practices Judaism is 100% of the time considered jew correct? and if people are making malicious jokes about jews, that's typically considered antisemitism. I do appreciate the definitions you sent though!

Also, I was temp banned for 5 days approximately 3 months ago from Basically Vanilla, the "CP joke" was me and another player messing around arguing and insulting each other, laughing the whole time. I then said "(players name) likes kids", roughly 10 mins later i was banned. Was it uncalled for, absolutely and ill own my mistake.

No disrespect, I'm not going to take your opinion seriously since you cant differentiate religion and a extremist group, and also try to do a smear campaign from just reading a headline and not doing your own research.
 
Im aware, but a person who practices Judaism is 100% of the time considered jew correct?
It's actually really interesting and more complicated than that.

Here's some brief Jewish Lore:

A person who is born to a jewish mother is jewish.
Some Jewish groups, namely reform, will view children of Jewish fathers, but non jewish mothers, as jewish only if they are raised jewishly.
You can also convert to become a Jew. You need to study Torah for a while with a rabbi for like a year or more, and it's a pain in the ass. Especially if you're a man.
You can "follow and practice judaism" without being jewish too. It's really fuckin weird, but some people do it.

Being "jewish" is more like being a part of a "nation" or "tribe". Like, all of us Jews are connected culturally and spiritually. We once had a homeland, although the modern version of that place is rather controversial. Not everyone prescribes to the religion of the tribe, either. There's a lot of Jewish athiests, because being Jewish is fucking crazy and complicated. Oh, and once you're in, you can never "leave" the tribe. We used to do excommunications like a few hundreds years ago, but we don't do that anymore.

But uh yeah to answer your question, basically yeah Jews are Jews 100% of the time lmfao
 
I think you need to educate yourself on geopolitics and the difference between Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism before making blanket statements. I'll make it easy for you: one is prejudice against Jews and one is opposition to a nationalist movement based on establishing a Jewish homeland through "colonization" that has lead to the genocide of the Palestinians.

Also, you were banned from Basically Vanilla for CP jokes so I'm not going to take your opinions seriously.
Would also like to just leave this here since its from your higher up :)

 
While I completely understand the concerns about antisemitic opinions and outright harassment, which I think is a valid concern to raise... I think this conversation is currently taking a spin away from being productive.
A lot of us, yours truly included, are currently disgruntled with the state of things. A lot of things weren't done that should have been done. A lot of things were done that shouldn't have been done.

I think where this thread truly shines is everyone laying out in a clear manner what they believe should or should not have been done. When it turns into mutual arguing over specific users, two of which are already banned and cannot defend themselves or state their perspective, then the thread begins to lose its purpose. This is also not a place to report or call for the bans of specific users, that is only going to make a bigger divide and upset in the community - and is itself a form of harassment. So if you experience something that you think warrants action, report it. This thread doesn't exist to define antisemitism vs antizionism or where - ethically and morally - the line between them is.
Please keep the conversation focused on how GL fucked up and what you would like GL to be. That is the feedback that's most needed right now. Arguing over semantic definitions of whether a behaviour or opinion was one thing or the other, is a different conversation that doesn't contribute much of value in this thread. Especially as it does not seem - to me - like you will be seeing eye to eye on this issue any time soon.

So please, pivot back to giving feedback or griping about Giant's Lair. Your voices are being heard by leadership and changes are coming. There are already some threads on the forums where you can give feedback for specific platforms, such as the Minecraft rules and how Discord is handled. So if you're interested in either of those conversations, by all means check them out and leave your feedback there too <3
 
Back
Top